Best KitchenArt Spice Carousel: Elite Auto-Measure vs Select-A-Spice (2026)
Best KitchenArt Spice Carousel: Elite Auto-Measure vs Select-A-Spice (2026)
Stuck between KitchenArt’s two auto-measure spice carousels? You’re not alone – both promise to declutter your cabinet and deliver precise seasoning with a twist or click, but they split on capacity, finish, and how they fit into your space. It’s the classic ‘do I need more compartments or a sleeker look?’ dilemma, and it’s easy to end up scrolling reviews without a clear direction.
KitchenArt has built a reputation for thoughtful kitchen organization, and these two models sit right in that sweet spot: tools that aim to make cooking faster and tidier. The Elite Auto-Measure and the Select-A-Spice both offer that handy auto-measure function, but they cater to slightly different kitchens and habits.
We’re going to break this down across the things that actually matter when you’re choosing: jar count versus compartment design, how the measurement feature holds up in real use, mounting flexibility, and which one just feels right in your hand. By the end, you’ll know exactly which carousel belongs in your cabinet.
Best KitchenArt Spice Carousel: Elite Auto-Measure vs Select-A-Spice (2026)
Elite Auto-Measure – Satin Finish 8-Jar Carousel
A stylish, satin-finished carousel with eight 3.5-ounce jars, featuring a click-based auto-measure system for precise 1/4 teaspoon dispensing.
Select-A-Spice – Black 12-Compartment Organizer
A high-capacity carousel with twelve compartments, featuring a twist-dial auto-measure system and options for under-cabinet mounting or stacking.
How We Evaluated KitchenArt Elite Auto-Measure and Select-A-Spice
We didn’t run these through a month of daily cooking in a test kitchen. What we did: triangulated KitchenArt’s published specifications, owner-reported experiences where available, and use-case fit against typical home cook profiles. We placed the Elite Auto-Measure and Select-A-Spice side-by-side across six decision axes: capacity, measurement functionality, material durability, dimensions, mounting options, and included accessories. Where the two aligned – on three fundamentals like auto-measure intent and plastic construction – we noted the overlap. Where they diverged – on three axes including jar count and finish – we surfaced the deltas to clarify which model suits your spice habits. Our goal isn’t to crown a winner; it’s to match each cook to the carousel that minimizes cabinet chaos.
KitchenArt Elite Auto-Measure vs Select-A-Spice: Which One Should You Buy?
1. Head-to-Head Breakdown: Elite Auto-Measure vs Select-A-Spice
To see the differences at a glance, here’s a direct comparison across key specs and features derived from the product information.
| Dimension | Elite Auto-Measure | Select-A-Spice |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | 8 jars (3.5 oz each) | 12 compartments (size not specified) |
| Measurement Feature | Click for 1/4 tsp | Twist dial for 1/4 tsp |
| Material | Plastic with satin finish | Plastic with black finish |
| Dimensions (D x W x H) | 7.5″ x 7.5″ x 9″ | 8.75″ x 8.75″ x 6″ |
| Mounting Options | Under cabinet or stackable | Under cabinet or countertop |
| Included Labels | 16 labels | 55 labels |
The biggest swings come down to capacity and measurement method – choose based on whether you need more spices or a specific dispensing feel.
2. Who Should Choose the KitchenArt Elite Auto-Measure?
Pick the Elite Auto-Measure if your spice collection fits comfortably in eight jars and you value a stylish, satin finish that elevates your kitchen decor. It’s perfect for cooks who prefer a click-based measurement system and need the flexibility to double-stack or mount for space savings. If you’re after a moderate organizer with a touch of elegance, this is your match.
3. Who Should Choose the KitchenArt Select-A-Spice?
Go with the Select-A-Spice if you have an extensive spice arsenal that demands twelve compartments. It’s ideal for those who appreciate a twist-dial auto-measure for quick dispensing and want ample labeling options with 55 included tags. Choose this if under-cabinet mounting is key to your kitchen layout and you prefer a sleek black design that maximizes storage without clutter.
4. Where the Elite Auto-Measure and Select-A-Spice Overlap
Both carousels share core strengths: they’re made from durable plastic, feature a rotating base for easy access, and include an auto-measure function aimed at simplifying cooking. Either will help organize your spices and reduce cabinet mess – so if your decision hinges on these shared traits, you can’t go wrong with either model.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What's the main difference between KitchenArt's Elite Auto-Measure and Select-A-Spice carousels?
The primary difference is capacity: the Elite has eight jars, while the Select-A-Spice has twelve compartments. Additionally, the measurement method varies – one uses clicks, the other a twist dial – and the finishes differ (satin vs. black).
2. Which KitchenArt spice carousel has better measurement accuracy?
Both aim for a 1/4 teaspoon measure, but feedback is mixed on accuracy for each. The Elite Auto-Measure’s click system can sometimes clog, while the Select-A-Spice’s twist dial may deliver inconsistently. For precision, have a backup spoon handy with either model.
3. Can I mount both KitchenArt carousels under a cabinet?
Yes, both models support under-cabinet mounting. The Elite Auto-Measure can also be stacked, and the Select-A-Spice offers countertop use as an alternative.
4. Are the jars in the Elite Auto-Measure interchangeable with the Select-A-Spice compartments?
No, the designs are different – the Elite uses individual jars, while the Select-A-Spice has integrated compartments. They’re not cross-compatible, so stick with the model that matches your storage style.
5. Which is better for a small kitchen: Elite Auto-Measure or Select-A-Spice?
For small spaces, consider the Select-A-Spice if you need more spices in a compact footprint (it’s shorter in height), or the Elite Auto-Measure if you prefer stacking to save horizontal space. Both offer mounting to free up counter area.
Final Verdict
This isn’t about which spice carousel is objectively better – it’s about which fits your kitchen and habits. Choose the KitchenArt Elite Auto-Measure if you have a moderate spice collection, value a stylish satin finish, and like the idea of a click-based measure. Choose the KitchenArt Select-A-Spice if you need capacity for twelve spices, prefer a twist-dial dispenser, and want maximum labeling options with a sleek black look. Either way, you’re getting a tool that makes cooking a bit more organized and a lot less frustrating.